Skip to content
Section 1 · அறத்துப்பால் (Virtue) · Chapter 20 / 133

Not Speaking Useless Words

பயனில சொல்லாமை
Kural 200

சொல்லுக சொல்லின் பயனுடைய சொல்லற்க
சொல்லின் பயனிலாச் சொல்.

solluka solliṉ payaṉuṭaiya sollaṟka / solliṉ payaṉilās sol

Modern readingAI draft

Speak words that carry benefit; never speak words that carry none.

Other translations · Pope (1886) & Aiyar (1916)
G.U. Pope1886

If speak you will, speak words that fruit afford, / If speak you will, speak never fruitless word.

V.V.S. Aiyar1916

Speak thou the speech that bringeth forth profit: but speak not ever words that are profitless and vain.

Read for

The Kural in life

AI draft · Pending review
In everyday life

The whole chapter in one line.

Valluvar closes with a rule so plain it can be carried for life: speak the words that carry benefit; never speak the words that carry none. Everything the chapter argued — the contempt, the lost dignity, the chaff, the clear mind — distils into this single test applied to each thing you are about to say.

Parimelazhagar: a clear command of what to say and what not.

Parimelazhagar reads the closing couplet as a deliberate summing-up: of words, speak those that have benefit; of words, do not speak those that have none. By this, he notes, what may be spoken and what may not are firmly fixed. The repeated 'of words' is no accident of style but a frame that holds the two halves of the rule together.

A test you can actually use.

What makes this ending powerful is its usability: it converts a whole ethic of speech into a single yes-or-no question you can ask in real time — does this carry benefit? If yes, say it; if no, let it go. You will not always judge perfectly, but the habit of asking is itself most of the discipline. Make benefit the gate every sentence has to pass, and the chapter's harder warnings rarely need to apply to you.

The pattern named

Speak words that carry benefit; never speak words that carry none.

Valluvar closes with a rule plain enough to carry for life: speak words that carry benefit, never words that carry none. Parimelazhagar reads it as a deliberate summing-up that firmly fixes what may be spoken and what may not. Everything the chapter argued distils into this single test applied to each thing you're about to say.

The counsel

Make benefit the gate every sentence has to pass.

What makes this ending powerful is its usability: it converts a whole ethic of speech into one yes-or-no question you can ask in real time — does this carry benefit? If yes, say it; if no, let it go. You won't always judge perfectly, but the habit of asking is itself most of the discipline. Make benefit the gate every sentence passes, and the chapter's harder warnings rarely need apply to you.

The Tamil heart
பயன்payaṉபயன் means benefit, fruit, use, result — the yield a thing produces. The whole chapter turns on it, and the last verse states the rule twice around it: speak the சொல் with பயன், not the சொல் without. English 'benefit' or 'fruit' is close; பயன் is the single measure Valluvar hands you for all speech — not 'is it clever, pleasing, or true?' first, but 'does it bear fruit?'